Create or Perish: The Case for Inventions and Patents
Not rated yetRate this bookCreate or Perish by Robert H. Rines examines invention, patent institutions, inventor difficulties, and reform from a strongly pro-invention perspective. These study instructions follow the introduction and nine chapters of the preliminary edition, focusing on how technical ideas, institutional decisions, and incentives interact.
Free reading is available at the official source. Opens in a new tab.
FreeAbout this book
Create or Perish by Robert H. Rines examines invention, patent institutions, inventor difficulties, and reform from a strongly pro-invention perspective. These study instructions follow the introduction and nine chapters of the preliminary edition, focusing on how technical ideas, institutional decisions, and incentives interact.
How to study this book
Maintain a three-column notebook for technical facts, institutional arrangements, and the author’s evaluations. After each chapter, ask which actor makes a decision, what information is available, and how incentives could affect the outcome. Use the text for historical and critical analysis rather than treating it as an up-to-date legal manual.
Chapter-wise explanations and study tasks
Introduction — Invention in Its Social Setting
The introduction places patents within social, political, and economic conditions and states the author’s support for inventive incentives. Begin by identifying the evaluative standard behind his idea of a successful system.
Study task: Define the public outcome the author wants patents to promote and distinguish it from an inventor’s private objective.
Chapter 1 — Development of the American Patent System
The history supplies a setting for the relationship between exclusive rights and inventive activity. A chronological association is different from evidence that a particular institutional feature caused a result.
Study task: Select a historical example and propose an alternative explanation for the development the author attributes to patent incentives.
Chapter 2 — Patent Office and Courts
Examination and judicial action involve different decisions and responsibilities. The chapter’s criticism becomes clearer when each stage is connected with the information, authority, and uncertainty facing its decision-makers.
Study task: Draw an institution-and-information diagram for the process described in the chapter.
Chapter 3 — Patent Law
The law chapter presents the period’s categories and tests alongside commentary on how inventions are recognized. Keep the technical description of an idea separate from the legal question the author discusses.
Study task: Analyze a hypothetical historical invention by separating its technical novelty claim from the legal questions raised by the text.
Chapter 4 — Patents in Action: The Telephone
The telephone history demonstrates how technical development and competing claims enter a legal and commercial contest. Study the role of the patent’s description and the reasoning attributed to the courts.
Study task: Compare the technical accounts in the case and identify which disputed point the author treats as decisive.
Chapter 5 — Inventors’ Rights, Obligations, and Problems
Inventors interact with employers, universities, government bodies, and potential partners. The chapter highlights the gap between creating an invention and successfully navigating ownership and negotiation relationships.
Study task: Create a fictional inventor case and list the unanswered institutional questions before proposing any action.
Chapter 6 — Future of American Patents
The reform discussion asks whether changes to searching, challenges, and technical decision-making could improve the system. Evaluate each proposal against the problem it is intended to address.
Study task: Make a problem–proposal table and identify one proposal whose success would depend on an untested behavioral assumption.
Chapter 7 — Modernization of Patent Systems
The modernization chapter compares approaches to institutional revision, including historical European proposals. Similar goals can lead to different arrangements for review, coordination, and decision authority.
Study task: Explain how two institutional designs could pursue consistent decisions while creating different practical trade-offs.
Chapter 8 — Court Modernization
The treatment of technical disputes raises questions about expertise and how it is used in decision-making. Consider both the benefit of technical understanding and the safeguards needed in a proposed process.
Study task: Draft a fictional technical-review procedure and critique it from the viewpoints of two opposing parties.
Chapter 9 — Economic Decline and Creativity
The conclusion connects institutional habits and attitudes toward originality with the broader inventive environment. Examine whether the proposed cultural explanation is supported by the evidence or remains an argument for further investigation.
Study task: Design a research question that could test one claim about conformity and inventive activity.
Applied assignment
Prepare an inventor-centered historical case study. Choose a case from the book, map the technical development and institutional relationships, identify the author’s causal explanation, and compare it with a plausible alternative. Finish with questions for further research rather than recommendations based on unverified historical law.
Suggested reading plan
Use Chapters 1–3 to understand the institutional vocabulary, Chapters 4–5 to study technical and personal cases, and Chapters 6–9 to examine reform and the wider inventive environment. Read the introduction first and return to it when judging whether the conclusion follows.
Questions for reflection
- Which obstacle is technical, contractual, institutional, or cultural?
- What evidence would distinguish a systemic problem from a difficult individual case?
- How can technical expertise inform a decision without replacing the need for a fair process?
Edition and source notes
The linked preliminary edition is transcribed for MIT OpenCourseWare and ends with the Fall 2005 Inventions and Patents course notice. Its substantive text matches the Spring 2008 course-linked copy on the other Create or Perish page in this batch. This guide gives the same historical book a distinct study emphasis and does not imply a revised edition.
This page provides book information and study material. Full-text access is provided by the original publisher or authorised source; a listing does not grant permission to republish the book.
Read our Library Access & Copyright policyExplore the contents
Check the chapters covered in this edition.
Visit the official source
See reading, preview or purchase options.
Save for later
Keep this textbook in your saved collection.
Reader ratings & reviews
Share your thoughts
Your review helps other students choose the right resources.









