Project Evaluation: Essays and Case Studies
Not rated yetRate this bookCarl D. Martland’s Project Evaluation: Essays and Case Studies connects the public purpose of infrastructure with the engineering, economic, and financial reasoning needed to assess it. The linked MIT download contains both Volume I and Volume II. This guide follows that complete collection, including its essays and applied cases.
Free reading is available at the official source. Opens in a new tab.
FreeAbout this book
Carl D. Martland’s Project Evaluation: Essays and Case Studies connects the public purpose of infrastructure with the engineering, economic, and financial reasoning needed to assess it. The linked MIT download contains both Volume I and Volume II. This guide follows that complete collection, including its essays and applied cases.
How to study this book
Start by defining the proposed service, affected stakeholders, and alternatives, including a baseline. Keep a decision journal that separates evidence from assumptions and distinguishes public outcomes from the operator’s cash flows. Volume I frames the project and its institutional setting; Volume II supplies the lifetime financial and risk analysis.
Chapter-wise explanations and study tasks
Volume I, Essay 1 — Introduction and Evaluation Framework
The opening asks where infrastructure proposals come from and how projects fit into wider programs and systems. Evaluation begins with society’s needs, possible alternatives, and a clear framework for judging outcomes rather than with a preferred design.
Study task: Frame one infrastructure need and propose three responses, including an option that changes operations rather than adding construction.
Volume I, Essay 2 — Basic Economic Concepts
Supply, demand, pricing, productivity, trade, utility, and sunk costs provide a vocabulary for evaluating infrastructure choices. Connect these concepts to the physical services a project delivers rather than treating them as detached definitions.
Study task: Explain how a change in a transport price can affect demand and why a past expenditure should not determine a forward-looking choice.
Volume I, Essay 3 — Public Perspectives
Economic, environmental, social, safety, and security concerns widen the appraisal beyond financial profit. A benefit–cost calculation and a regional economic-impact estimate answer different questions and should not be added together without examining overlap.
Study task: Prepare a stakeholder-impact matrix and mark effects that risk being counted twice.
Volume I, Essay 4 — Comparing Strategies
The comparison of strategies brings together discounted measures, cost effectiveness, weighting schemes, and public input. A numerical score depends on the criteria and weights selected, so transparency matters as much as arithmetic.
Study task: Rank three improvement strategies using stated weights, then test which weight change would reverse the preferred option.
Volume I, Essay 5 — Public–Private Partnerships
Partnerships are examined as arrangements for investment, responsibilities, and public objectives. The Highway 407 and Newfoundland examples encourage readers to ask what a partnership is intended to accomplish and how its framework affects incentives.
Study task: Draft a partnership responsibility table covering construction, demand, financing, operations, and oversight.
Volume I, Essay 6 — Evolution of Infrastructure-Based Systems
The eight-stage account traces experimentation, implementation, consolidation, advancement, competition, impact mitigation, and possible obsolescence. Systems evolve through institutional and social changes as well as technical improvements.
Study task: Place a chosen infrastructure system at a defensible stage and identify evidence that challenges your classification.
Volume I, Case — The Franconia Notch Parkway
This case places a transport project within a sensitive setting. Use it to examine how project objectives and constraints interact rather than assuming that maximum traffic capacity is the only measure of success.
Study task: Compare a capacity objective with an environmental objective and formulate a design criterion that makes the trade-off explicit.
Volume I, Case — Weighting Bus-Capacity Options
The bus-capacity comparison makes the consequences of a multicriteria weighting scheme visible. Separate estimates of performance from judgments about how important each measure should be.
Study task: Construct two stakeholder weighting schemes and explain why the same option can receive different rankings.
Volume I, Case — The Panama Canal
The canal history links route choice, earlier transport alternatives, engineering attempts, institutions, and changing world trade. Read the sequence as a changing decision context rather than as a project whose later success was obvious from the start.
Study task: Build a timeline showing how technical information and institutional control changed the feasibility of the canal.
Volume I, Case — Pearl River Delta: More than a Bridge
The regional case broadens attention from a single structure to the transport and development system it would serve. Study how the team framed the problem and why that framing matters for the alternatives considered.
Study task: Define a regional access problem and explain how it differs from deciding where to place one bridge.
Volume I, Case — Scenario Planning at Southern California Edison
Scenario planning examines different plausible futures instead of treating one forecast as certain. Its value lies in exposing decisions that are vulnerable to particular assumptions and identifying strategies that remain useful across futures.
Study task: Write three internally consistent energy-demand scenarios and identify an investment that is robust across them.
Volume I, Case — Financing a Bridge Project
The bridge discussion compares state provision, private toll financing, and partnership possibilities. Read it first as a question about public objectives and responsibilities, then connect it with the financial treatment in Volume II.
Study task: Specify the public outcomes that a bridge financing agreement should protect before calculating a private return.
Volume I, Case — Public Incentives for Low-Income Housing
The housing case examines how a public incentive changes development choices. Keep the public housing objective distinct from the financial inducement used to pursue it.
Study task: Define a measurable housing outcome and explain what evidence would be needed to attribute it to an incentive.
Volume I, Case — The Sheffield Flyover
The Kansas City flyover illustrates a targeted infrastructure intervention and the lessons drawn from its results. Focus on the operational problem and the connection between local improvements and wider system performance.
Study task: Draw the bottleneck before and after the intervention and list outcome measures that could verify an improvement.
Volume I, Case — Skyscrapers and Building Booms
The real-estate case connects long-lived construction with expectations and changing market conditions. Consider the timing mismatch between a development decision, completion, and the demand that ultimately materializes.
Study task: Construct a development timeline and explain how a demand forecast error can persist after a building is completed.
Volume I, Case — Evolution of the U.S. Rail System
The rail history combines expansion, accidents, market power, regulation, deregulation, and technological change. Use it to test the essay’s stages of infrastructure evolution without forcing every historical event into a rigid sequence.
Study task: Select three institutional or technical changes and explain how each altered the rail system’s incentives or performance.
Volume I, Case — Rehabilitating Newark’s Brick Sewers
The sewer example brings rehabilitation into an evaluation framework often associated with new construction. Compare retaining and improving existing assets with replacement, including the service consequences of each strategy.
Study task: Prepare a rehabilitation-versus-replacement comparison that includes disruption and remaining service life.
Volume I — Final Thoughts and Further Reading
The closing material returns to judgment in project evaluation and points toward further study. Use it to check whether your assessment has addressed the original public need and the uncertainty in its assumptions.
Study task: Write a one-page evaluation framework and identify two gaps that require further investigation.
Volume II, Essay 1 — System Performance
The financial volume begins by grounding evaluation in capacity, service, cost, and safety. Performance measures must refer to a defined system and operating conditions before they can support a cash-flow forecast.
Study task: Translate one Volume I project objective into an operational measure and a corresponding cost or revenue assumption.
Volume II, Essay 2 — Equivalence of Cash Flows
The time value of money allows construction, operation, maintenance, and later benefits to be expressed on a common basis. Interest conventions and the placement of each flow on a timeline determine the conversion.
Study task: Build a dated cash-flow sheet and verify one present-value calculation using an equivalent annual amount.
Volume II, Essay 3 — Choosing a Discount Rate
A defensible discount rate should match the viewpoint and assumptions of the evaluation. Test how the rate changes the influence of distant effects rather than describing a rate-sensitive result as an objective ranking.
Study task: Compare a short-lived and a long-lived alternative across a range of rates and interpret the crossover.
Volume II, Essay 4 — Financial Assessment
Project life, inflation, net present value, and rates of return must be used consistently. Independent projects and mutually exclusive choices require different decision logic, particularly when their lives or cash-flow patterns differ.
Study task: Compare two alternatives using a common study period and state how you treat inflation and residual value.
Volume II, Essay 5 — Rules of the Game
Taxes, depreciation, and regulation alter the feasible design and the distribution of cash flows. Record these rules as explicit contextual assumptions rather than hiding them inside a single cost estimate.
Study task: Add a simplified depreciation schedule to a project model and separate accounting expense, cash expense, and tax effect.
Volume II, Essay 6 — Risk and Uncertainty
Uncertainty concerns both numerical inputs and the performance of technologies and institutions. The essay develops ways to investigate those uncertainties before making a decision on the strength of one favorable forecast.
Study task: Choose a project risk, model its consequence, and compare prevention with contingency planning.
Volume II, Case 1 — Bus Service Function
The bus case makes the link from engineering choices to deliverable service explicit. The resulting service function can support cost and revenue calculations only if operating assumptions are realistic.
Study task: Derive the effect of a longer round-trip time on fleet requirements while holding service frequency fixed.
Volume II, Case 2 — Highway Intersection Capacity
An intersection provides a compact example of capacity constraints and operating design. Identify the critical movement or phase and explain how a physical change would affect throughput.
Study task: Compare the benefit of changing a lane arrangement with changing signal allocation under the same demand assumptions.
Volume II, Case 3 — Early Canal Projects
Canal economics depend on the service offered, construction costs, demand, and competing routes or technologies. The case supplies a setting for joining a service model with lifetime financial assessment.
Study task: Test a canal proposal under two competing-transport scenarios and explain which forecast matters most.
Volume II, Case 4 — Manhattan Office Tower
The office-tower study connects a construction decision with future rental and operating cash flows. The interval between expenditure and occupancy makes timing a central source of financial exposure.
Study task: Estimate how a one-year completion delay changes NPV and distinguish the delay cost from a fall in occupancy.
Volume II, Case 5 — Stadium and Multiple IRRs
The stadium example demonstrates a weakness of internal-rate-of-return reasoning when the cash-flow sequence is nonconventional. A decision needs the full NPV behavior, not merely one reported percentage.
Study task: Construct an NPV profile and explain what you would report if several discount rates produced zero NPV.
Volume II, Case 6 — Housing Incentives
Revisit the housing problem as a cash-flow intervention as well as a social policy. Calculate what the incentive changes for the developer, then assess whether that change plausibly serves the public objective defined in Volume I.
Study task: Create separate developer and public ledgers and mark transfers between them.
Volume II, Case 7 — Bridge Financing
Revisit the bridge through the financial feasibility of state, private, and partnership options. A financing structure changes risk allocation and payments but does not automatically create additional underlying service benefits.
Study task: Compare three financing options using the same traffic forecast and identify the source of any apparent gain.
Volume II, Case 8 — Probabilistic Financial Risk
The probabilistic example explores the range of financial outcomes generated by uncertain inputs. The result is only as informative as the distributions and relationships assumed between those inputs.
Study task: Document a small simulation, show a downside measure, and test whether an assumed correlation changes the conclusion.
Volume II, Case 9 — Intercity Passenger Technology
Technology scanning connects technical performance with travel time, utility, mode share, and the operation of carriers and terminals. Evaluate an entire service system rather than a vehicle’s headline speed.
Study task: Compare two intercity systems on door-to-door service and identify the assumptions linking service quality to demand.
Volume II, Case 10 — Grade-Crossing Safety
The grade-crossing case examines a project whose main objective is reduced accident risk. A useful comparison makes exposure, expected consequences, intervention cost, and effectiveness transparent.
Study task: Rank two safety interventions and test whether uncertainty in effectiveness could change your recommendation.
Volume II — Equivalence-Factor Appendix
The appendix supplies factors for checking interest and cash-flow calculations. Match each factor to the actual timing pattern and verify that your computational tool uses the same convention.
Study task: Check one spreadsheet result against an appendix factor and explain any difference caused by timing or rounding.
Applied assignment
Submit an integrated evaluation of an infrastructure proposal. Use Volume I to define the need, alternatives, affected groups, environmental and social criteria, and institutional arrangement. Use Volume II to build the service model, lifetime cash flows, financial comparison, and uncertainty assessment. Finish with a conditional recommendation and the evidence that could change it.
Suggested reading plan
Read the six Volume I essays with their associated cases before making a first project outline. Work through the six Volume II essays to add calculations, then revisit the bridge and housing cases from both viewpoints. Finish with one probabilistic case and a final review of criteria, assumptions, and double counting.
Questions for reflection
- Does the preferred financial option address the public problem that motivated the project?
- Which apparent benefits are transfers between stakeholders?
- What additional information would most improve the decision before construction begins?
Edition and source notes
The MIT download combines Martland’s October 2016 Volumes I and II. Volume I focuses on creating infrastructure systems that meet society’s needs; Volume II compares lifetime economic and financial impacts. Bridge financing and housing incentives appear in both volumes, so this guide distinguishes their place in each rather than treating the combined file as Volume I alone.
This page provides book information and study material. Full-text access is provided by the original publisher or authorised source; a listing does not grant permission to republish the book.
Read our Library Access & Copyright policyExplore the contents
Check the chapters covered in this edition.
Visit the official source
See reading, preview or purchase options.
Save for later
Keep this textbook in your saved collection.
Reader ratings & reviews
Share your thoughts
Your review helps other students choose the right resources.







