PhilosophyHow to Think Critically
Not rated yetRate this bookStephanie Gibbons and Justine Kingsbury’s How to Think Critically develops the skills needed to identify, reconstruct, and evaluate arguments. This guide follows the 2024 University of Waikato textbook’s six chapters and supporting video transcripts, emphasizing good reasons and fair engagement rather than persuasive wording alone.
Free reading is available at the official source. Opens in a new tab.
FreeAbout this book
Stephanie Gibbons and Justine Kingsbury’s How to Think Critically develops the skills needed to identify, reconstruct, and evaluate arguments. This guide follows the 2024 University of Waikato textbook’s six chapters and supporting video transcripts, emphasizing good reasons and fair engagement rather than persuasive wording alone.
How to study this book
Attempt the embedded questions before reading feedback. Reconstruct an argument in numbered standard form, identify its intended support, and assess both the inference and the premises. Apply the same standards to claims you favour and oppose. Use the webbook for interactive activities omitted from the PDF.
Chapter-wise explanations and study tasks
1. Introduction
Arguments offer premises in support of a conclusion, and standard form makes that relationship inspectable. Distinguish a statement, a rhetorical flourish, and a reason before attempting evaluation. Critical thinking also examines the grounds of your own beliefs.
Study task: Rewrite a short persuasive passage as numbered premises and a conclusion, excluding material that changes tone without supplying support.
2. Deductive Arguments
Validity concerns whether true premises could coexist with a false conclusion, while soundness adds the truth of the premises. Common patterns and structural fallacies show why an argument’s form must be distinguished from agreement with its conclusion.
Study task: Construct a valid argument with a false premise and an invalid argument with a true conclusion, then explain why the labels still apply.
3. Reconstruction
Implicit premises, clarification, irrelevant material, complex support, and argument trees help reveal how a passage works. Add only what is needed and reasonably attributable to the speaker, making your interpretive choices explicit.
Study task: Reconstruct a multi-step argument with an intermediate conclusion and diagram which premises work jointly and which support it independently.
4. Non-deductive Arguments
Probability, enumeration, samples, analogy, causation, and inference to the best explanation provide support without deductive guarantees. Evaluate the particular evidence standard relevant to the inference rather than dismissing it for failing to entail certainty.
Study task: Compare an argument from a sample with an analogy on the same topic, identifying a distinct strength and weakness for each.
5. Soundness and Cogency
Evaluation includes premise credibility, normative claims, authorities, and relevant fallacies as well as the strength of support. A normative conclusion may require a value premise, while expertise must fit the question being answered.
Study task: Audit a claim relying on an authority, specifying the relevant expertise, evidence, possible limitations, and any unstated value assumption.
6. Fair Dealing
Charity, relevance, question begging, burden of proof, and arguments from ignorance govern how disagreements are handled. Criticism should engage the strongest reasonably supported version of the argument rather than replace it with an easier target.
Study task: Rewrite a fictional disagreement to remove a straw man and a personal attack, then state what each side would need to establish.
Interactive Practice and Video Transcripts
The book’s questions and transcripts support repeated practice in inference and reconstruction. A correct answer is more useful when you can explain why alternative answers fail and apply the distinction to a new case.
Study task: Complete a source activity, explain the reasoning behind the feedback, and create a new example testing the same skill.
Applied assignment
Prepare a fair-minded argument review containing the original claim, standard-form reconstruction, argument tree, classification of the inference, premise assessment, and response to the strongest objection. End with a revised conclusion proportionate to the evidence.
Suggested reading plan
Read chapters 1–2 for identification and deduction, 3 for reconstruction, 4 for nondeductive support, and 5–6 for complete evaluation and fair disagreement. Use the interactive questions throughout and return to earlier reconstructions after learning later tools.
Questions for reflection
- Have you evaluated the argument actually offered?
- Which premise needs evidence and which expresses a value?
- Would your standard change if you disliked the conclusion?
Edition and source notes
Based on the six-chapter 2024 University of Waikato edition, whose version history records publication on July 27, 2024. The linked PDF retains references to its earlier hosting location and excludes interactive H5P elements; use the official webbook for those activities.
This page provides book information and study material. Full-text access is provided by the original publisher or authorised source; a listing does not grant permission to republish the book.
Read our Library Access & Copyright policyExplore the contents
Check the chapters covered in this edition.
Visit the official source
See reading, preview or purchase options.
Save for later
Keep this textbook in your saved collection.
Reader ratings & reviews
Share your thoughts
Your review helps other students choose the right resources.








