“Vegetarianism in Adolescence” Essay
“A vegetarian is defined as a person whose food consists of only vegetables and vegetable products” (Dula). Many adults and children refuse to eat meat, but there are also people available who don’t like vegetables much. Both foods and food products are necessary for one’s life and health. Both contain vitamins, proteins, fats, etc. It is medically approved that meat contains more amount of energy than a vegetable. To meet all the requirement of one’s body, they should eat balanced food rather than depending on one. People refuse to eat meat because they are concerned about animal’s right and some for other reasons. Even though vegetarian teenagers are concern about animal rights or any other reasons to be healthier, being on a vegetarian diet is risky for their health. Depending on only one food can lead to a lack of nutrition and many other health diseases. A teenager should eat enough meats from animal-based products so that they can grow up healthily with sufficient nutrients.People become vegetarian for several reasons such as for weight loss, religious restriction, influenced by family and friends, concerns for animal rights and some can’t afford to buy meat, so they shift to vegetable. Some people quit eating meat because they want to avoid excessive use of environmental resources. In the present day becoming vegetarian has become easier because of the availability of plant-based diets around the year. “About 9 million adults including adolescents in the United States avoid eating meat and fish. About 2 million people completely avoid eating meat, fish, and animal-based products including eggs, cheese, milk, and gelatin” (Demory-Luce and Motil 01).
Most of the people become vegetarian because they are concerned about the rights of animals, those which are used as food. They think eating the meat of these animals is a violation of the animal rights as they think slaughtering of animals can be a murder which is not acceptable. Religious obligations are also an important factor of people being vegetarian; some religions prohibit the use of animal meat as it is not considered a good virtue to kill other beings just for their food. “Flesh food prohibitions such as the rejection of pork by Islam and Judaism, taboos relating to the slaughter of cattle and the consumption of beef among Hindus in India, and the strict vegetarianism associated with Jainism” (Beardsworth, Alan, & Teresa 256). These religious restrictions and taboos become a reason for people to quit eating meat.
Adolescents trends to adopt vegetarianism for many reasons such as to show their independence, become more intimate with their other peers, to establish their identity or just their rebellious attitude. They want to look different from their parent’s generation and want to take their decision by themselves. Therefore for many adolescents becoming a vegetarian may be the first informed, adult decision they make. It is also stated that “it might be a way to express these developmental needs that have noted for other behaviors such as smoking and use of alcohol” (Perry, Cheryl L., et al. 407). Adolescents are much concern about their appearance, and they put lots of emphasis on that. During adolescent emphasis on appearance increase comparative to the other age groups. “This preoccupation with appearance puts them at greater risk for adopting a variety of dietary patterns in an attempt to look attractive and thin according to current vogue” (Perry, Cheryl L., et al. 407).
Vegetarianism has become more common and popular in adolescent in recent time. Teenage is the age of growing of the body and brain. Therefore, it is necessary to eat sufficient food that contains the complete nutrient that is required by the body. The food of vegetarians may include healthier diet than meat eaters, but scientists have found that they may suffer from eating disorder.
“In a survey, about 10 percent of American girls aged from 10 to 18 regard themselves as vegetarian and some people completely exclude meat from their food. Individuals with increasing nutritional needs such as infants, adolescents, and pregnant women may face difficulty meeting their nutritional needs on vegans’ diet” (Meister 01).
Hence adolescent is the age of increased nutrition in that case if they depend only on vegetables will be harmful to their health. They will likely face several health issues and more likely will lose weight.
Depending only on vegetable will put their health at risk. The plant food does not contain all ingredients and vitamins which are needed by adolescent’s body. While depending only on vegetable, they are putting their health at risk. The restriction of food will result in a decrease in energy and could bring abundant harmful effects to the growing body of teenagers.
“Since the adolescent years are a time when bone density is determined the insufficient intake of calcium may cause weak bones because vegetables have lower calcium than meat. The high protein content of animal products, when it is metabolized, leaves a lot of acids in the body, sulfur and sulfuric acids and these acids help calcium to dissolve out in the bones” (Klaper 208).
Vegetables could not complete the amount of calcium needed for the body. To complete that percentage vegetarian needs to eat more and more.
Like calcium vegetable lack of many other essential vitamins required for the body especial for adolescents. Vitamin B12, iron, zinc and omega-3 fatty acid are found in vegetables but are in very less amount that cannot fulfill the requirements of the body. Vitamin B12 is necessary for blood formation and cell division if the intake of this vitamin is low the body will not be able to carry out cell division and blood formation usually because plant food does not contain this vitamin, so the vegetarians are more likely susceptible to this malfunctioning. The deficiency of vitamin B12 can also cause some serious health issues leading to irreversible nerve damage. To avoid this shortcoming, vegetarians intake supplementary that further complicate their health situation and cause pernicious anemia and neurological problems.
Similarly, iron is commonly thought to be lacking in plant foods. Particularly for girls, the consumption of iron is very important as compared to boys. Iron is the central part of hemoglobin which carries oxygen to the blood. If an appropriate amount of iron is not provided to the body, it can cause health issues. Dietary fiber prevents the absorption of non-heme iron by binding to it and dropping its bioavailability. The calcium phosphate, polyphenols, phytates or bran found in coffee, tea and soybean can reserve the absorption of non-heme iron putting vegetarians in a risk of iron deficiency.
Omega-3 fatty acids are important for the human body. It helps in the mental and brain growth of a person, so it is necessary for adolescents. It may be helpful in reducing the chances of cancer and cardiovascular disorders. Omega-3 fatty acids are found primarily in fishes or their oil as the vegetarians do not get much of this important fatty acid they can have a higher risk of health issues. Rough and dry bumpy skin, dull or dry hairs, sleeping problems, attention problems and emotional sensitivity these are some of the symptoms of deficiency of omega-3 fatty acids.
Zinc is also vital for the human health and is much needed during adolescence. Zinc plays a range of key roles to support healthy growth it is required to merger complex protein molecules into simpler amino acids that support brain function, and also support the growth and repair of muscle tissues.
“Zinc helps cells divide, which happens quickly and frequently during puberty, while it also builds and repairs DNA, the genetic material at the heart of all cells. Additionally, this powerful trace mineral speeds up reactions of about 100 enzymes some of them essential for digestion of foods for energy” (Bakan, Rita, et al. 229-233).
Thus zinc should be provided to the body in a preferable amount, but the vegetarian diet does not have an adequate amount of zinc, so they are much likely to have some abnormalities keeping in view the crucial role of zinc
Researchers have found that the percentage of an eating disorder is higher among vegetarians. Those who chose vegetables for weight loss are more likely to deal with the eating disorder problem. Constraints on eating animal based products for the purpose of weight loss will lead to eating disorder. Different groups of vegetarians and non-vegetarians who chose a reason other than weight loss such as religious concerns or taste preferences has lower levels of nutritional restraint than semi-vegetarians who limit eating of meat for their obesity. “They are also less likely to participate in healthy and unhealthy weight control behaviors than semi-vegetarians. Full vegetarianism may have played more of a role in the maintenance of eating disorder” (Timko, Alix, et al. 983). That adolescent who chose eating plant base food for the reason of their weight loss is now facing several medical issues including less growth of brain and eating disorder.
Being on a vegan diet can cause several other health issues such as sudden weight loss, hair fall, low blood pressure and many others. In girls, it can also create disturbance in their periods. Many people have quit vegetarianism because of these reasons. Researchers have also found that with all these problem vegetarianism has a direct effect on the brain thus causing mental illness and depression in adolescents. According to a German study, vegetarians were 15 percent more prone to depressive conditions and twice as likely to suffer anxiety disorders.
“On a biological level, nutrition status resulting from vegetarian diet may affect neuronal function and synaptic plasticity, which in turn influences brain processes relevant for onset and maintenance of mental disorders. Vegetarians have reported that “they have this terrible depression and anxiety, but they don’t know why” (Michalak, et al. 05).
The study compares a vegetarian adolescent with a non-vegetarian and found that vegetarians were more depressed than non-vegans. They are more likely to have expected and attempted suicide than non-vegetarians. In another study, the researchers found that young vegetarians were reported with more irregular eating behaviors, including intentional vomiting, laxative use and higher rates of dieting. They were also reported of having low self-esteem, high social anxiety, and abnormal eating attitudes. “They might be at increased risk of binge eating with loss of control and extreme unhealthful weight-control behaviors such as diet pills, intentional vomiting, used laxatives and diuretics” (Michalak, et al. 10). These studies and research show that vegetarianism has become dangerous for adolescents and has caused many serious health problems for them.
For a healthier body and brain adolescents needs to eat balanced food. Beef is the only power ingredient for a healthy and active brain. This is the age of their mental and physical growth. Therefore, it is important to eat meat, fish, and animal based products. Meat contains more vitamins and healthy nutrition than plan-based foods and products. For the better development of mental growth, it is vital to intake meat. But if they still want to become vegans, then they must consult their doctor or nutritionist for guidance.
Being vegetarian has several health benefits but if correctly follow the diet plan because eating few vegetables will result in a deficiency of essential ingredients proteins and vitamins in the body. Also, vegetables do not contain all the key elements which are needed for the body such as B12, iron, zinc and many other are lacking. To compensate these requirements of the body adolescent vegetarians should eat whole soy foods, hemp seeds, chia seeds, flaxseeds, dark leafy greens, walnuts and wheat germ. To compensate the requirement of proteins, they should eat seeds, nuts, whole soy foods, beans, and quinoa regularly. A vegetarian diet is good as long as the essential nutrients found in animal products are compensated.
Adolescent vegetarians should be concerned about their health rather than exercising their independence or the power of making a decision. It seems they are much concern about their appearance, look and animal’s right than their health. “Vegetarians were significantly more likely to care about eating healthy food and less likely to care about being healthy” (Perry, Cheryl L., et al. 411). Vegetables are healthy, but they can cause in weight loss and deficiency of many essential elements in the body which will result in several health issues such as eating disorder, mental illness, and physical weakness.
It is very important for the adolescent to have a balanced diet because they are at the age of mental and physical growth. If they ignore their health for appearance and look it will be very harmful to them in the future and as well in the current situation. Especially for girls, it is extremely dangerous because they will lose weight and it will cause a disturbance in their period which will later create a problem during pregnancy and delivery. Giving birth to a child is not easy numerous women have died during childbirth because lacking the tendency of bearing pain and several other reasons. The disturbance in period can also affect pregnancy and childbirth.
Any individual decide to adopt vegetarianism must consult their physician first. They should also consider the decision of their parents because they have more experience and knowledge about what is better and what is worst. Being vegetarian has many health benefits such as lower serum total and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol concentration, a lower rate of coronary heart disease and cancer, lower blood pressure, low body weights and healthier lifestyle than non-vegetarians. But with all these health benefits it has some dangerous and severe health issues such as depression, anxiety, eating disorder and they are more likely to kill themselves.
The main problem which is concerning for doctors and parents is the increase in depression, mental illness and suicidal approach of adolescent vegetarians. These have raised concern for parents and physicians. It is significant to counsel adolescent on the issues created by vegetarianism properly. They should be rightly guided that when and how to shift to vegetarian is it necessary for them or not. Their decision should not be random and without any consultant from anyone. If they decided to become vegetarian, they must be guided what to eat to overcome the deficiencies created by vegetables. They should be aware of the pros and cons of vegetarians. Before putting their life at risk, they must be guided by their nutritionist about the foods they should intake. Being on a vegetarian diet is a great thing but as long as the nutrients found in animal based products are compensated. The vegetarians should not avoid all the animal products because the plan based food does not contain all the ingredients which are needed by the body.
Bakan, Rita, et al. “Dietary zinc intake of vegetarian and nonvegetarian patients with anorexia nervosa.” International Journal of Eating Disorders 13.2 (1993): 229-233.
Beardsworth, Alan, and Teresa Keil. “The vegetarian option: varieties, conversions, motives, and careers.” The Sociological Review 40.2 (1992): 253-293.
Demory-Luce, Debby, and Kathleen J Motil, “Vegetarian Diets For Children.” Uptodate.com. N.p., 2017. Web. 13 June 2017.
Dula, Adrianne. “Vegetarianism For Adolescents.” Healthpsych.psy.vanderbilt.edu. N.p., 2017. Web. 13 June 2017.
Klaper, Micheal. National for Optimum Health, 2002.
Meister, Kathleen. Vegetarianism. Am Cncl on Science, Health, 1997.
Michalak, Johannes, Xiao Chi Zhang, and Frank Jacobi. “Vegetarian diet and mental disorders:results from a representative community survey.” International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity 9.1 (2012): 67.
Perry, Cheryl L., et al. “Characteristics of vegetarian adolescents in a multiethnic urban population.” Journal of Adolescent Health 29.6 (2001): 406-416.
Timko, C. Alix, Julia M. Hormes, and Janice Chubski. “Will the real vegetarian please stand up?An investigation of dietary restraint and eating disorder symptoms in vegetarians versus non-vegetarians.” Appetite 58.3 (2012): 982-990.