Allegiance Coal Limited is a publicly listed company based in Australia and listed on the Austrilian Securities Exchange (ASX: AHQ). The company main business activities include investment in advanced and near production in metallurgical coal in countries like British Columbia, Canada. The company is involved in the acquisition and exploration of coal tenements with other potential countries of investments. The choice of its countries’ investment is based on factors such as countries with good investment record and low level of political upheavals or risks. Allegiance Coal Limited bases its assessment of its projects on capital expenditure which is not prohibitive but less costly before making any investment. The company is committed to build a sustainable working environment with the local people with whom it engages in its investment projects.
With its presence in other countries the company faces significant business and audit risks. Some of the notable risks include fluctuations in the currency, stiff competition from other firms, interruption of its business operations, seasonal factors and risks associated with taxation. The above highlighted risks affect the company’s financial performance and audit review should be performed to assess them during audit processes.
This report of Allegiance Coal Limited will encompass financial performance by looking into the following financial ratios; current ratio, quick ratio, gearing ratio, debt ratio, profitability ratio such as ordinary earnings per share and finally assessment of the management efficiency based on the return on equity. Analysis of the company’s financial ratios and interpretation indicates the company has a better financial performance in comparison with the industry averages. The audit and assurance process of Allegiance Coal Limited especially on the risks and financial assessment of shows areas of risk of material misstatement which are crucial areas of interest for an auditor. Revenues and assets are items which are usually prone to the risk of material misstatement. Allegiance Coal Limited is actively engaged in sustainable development programs with the indigenous in areas of its presence by building sustainable working relationships. These areas of sustainable development assurance also need external audit assurance to ascertain the risks.
- Introduction and Business Overview
Allegiance Coal Limited is an international Australian firm established in 2011 and headquartered in New South Wales, Australia. The company is involved in the acquisition and exploration of metallurgical coal tenements. It has flagship project called Telkwa metallurgical coal project based in British Colombia, Canada. The company also has an interest in Back Creek project in Central Queensland parts of the Australia. Other projects include Kilmain project in the Bowen Basin.
Allegiance Coal Limited acquired Telkwa Coal Limited on 23rd November 2016 after the approval by its shareholders. The project is located in British Colombia and enjoys access to rail and port from the Ridley Island Terminal. This proximity creates a short shipping distance to the Asian steel mills. TCL has engaged in exploration and evaluation projects costing substantial amounts of capital. TCL adjacent location to Canadian National Railway line provides access to cheap haulage saving significant amount in capital and operation costs.
The company has drilled significant number of coal holes totaling 828 holes both for rotary and core. Drilled coal samples are sent to laboratories for testing and analysis. Analytical testing of coal involves seam analysis, testing of the product, complete wash ability analysis and burn tests. Since the acquisition of the Telkwa Coal Limited the company has successfully conducted drilling and bulk sampling programme with no safety related incidents. Substantial amount of coal has been drilled from the mine and transported to other mineral testing fields across Canada.
To ensure proper management of its business operation in Canada Allegiance Coal Limited has made significant changes in its executive composition. At the board level, Mr. Fawcett who held the position of a non executive director has been appointed the chairman of the Non Executive dethroning Mr. Malcolm Carson. Mr. Carson was the chairman who oversaw the acquisition of Telkwa project and the completion of two pre-feasibility studies in the year 2017. In his capacity he delivered outstanding results and he will still remain Non Executive Director.
In 2017 Allegiance Company was able to locate nine groundwater wells which were installed 20 years ago by former project owners. Several of the well was in good working conditions which meant a reduction in the cost associated with drilling new wells. The same year the company completed pre-feasibility studies of the projects which were conducted by SRK Consulting Company. This was done to ensure that production is safe and the mines are environmentally sustainable for a quicker, affordable and achievable production. The pre-feasibility studies projected mining of about 250,000 tones of saleable coal for the first year and subsequent increase in the coming years.
The annual report about its financial for the years end 31st December 2017 indicated huge losses majorly attributed by the heavy investment and acquisition which the company undertook and the related capital expenditure projects. Revenues plummeted and as at 31st December it stood at AUD 3,090 against what was recorded a year ago (AUD 5,041). There was a significant loss before income tax expense during the year 2017. However, with the current investment the company has undertaken it has projected increase in revenues in the coming years due to increase in mining quantity of coal (ASX News 1).
- Significant Business and Audit Risk for Allegiance Coal Limited
Allegiance Coal Limited faces both business and audit risk which undermines it operations. Business risks are those events which a business encounters during the normal operation of its business that affects its stability and revenues. Some of the business risks that Allegiance Coal Limited faces include market risks, financial risks, compliance risk and strategic risks. Audits risks are those risks associated with material misstatements in the financial statement of a company. Risks affect the audit outcomes and impact on the operations of the company’s business. The above risks are discussed below.
- Foreign Currency Risk
Allegiance Coal Limited is an Australian multi-national company with and headquartered in New South Wales, Australia and with presence in British Colombia, Canada where it has a major flagship project- Telkwa Limited. This implies that the company deals with different foreign currency subject to the foreign exchange risk as a result of the fluctuations in the foreign exchange rates. Changes in the exchange rates affect the expected cash flow for the company. These changes in the foreign rates also lead to the transaction risks which occur during sales and purchases of materials. Revenues that the company makes in Canada dollar from its business in Canada has to be changed to Australian dollar relative to the prevailing foreign exchange rate and this affects the overall revenues and profitability of the company. Pricing risks which usually arise due to fluctuations in currency rates also affect purchases of supplies and materials. Translation risks also arise when the company is consolidating its financial statements into one currency. A clearly strategy should be developed to help mitigate these risks which could lead to material misstatements during the audit process. In the 2017 annual report of Allegiance Coal Limited, Note 20 Financial Instruments, the company has a financial risk management program to mitigate this risk by using derivatives such as forward foreign exchange instruments (ALLEGINCE COAL, ANNUAL REPORT 2017, p.55).
- Tax Risks
Allegiance Coal Limited operation as multinational company with its presence in other countries exposes it to various dynamic and unique tax environments. During various tax regulations in different countries and regular amendments it becomes difficult for the company to report on tax and declare profits accurately. The various interpretations of tax laws make it difficult to consolidate financial statements of the business. Besides being a business risk, tax risks is also an audit risk to the business. Due to differing interpretation of tax laws there is likelihood of material misstatement occurring during audit procedures. It is therefore important that the audit process within the company entails the assessment of this exposed audit risks.
- Business Interruptions Risks
This is another risk which could potential impact on the operations of a business. This is risk is associated with occurrence of unexpected events and disasters during the normal operations of a business. Some of these risks especially in regard to coal mining include earthquakes, floods and bad weather. The occurrence of these unexpected events will affect the operations of Allegiance Coal Limited and ultimately affect profitability. These events could as well affect the value of assets. It is therefore important for a business to assess the business interruption risk during auditing to explain the changes in the business financials as a result of these occurrences.
- Commodity Price Risk
This risk is a result of the adverse movement in price of metallurgical coal. Changes in the price of coal lead to decrease in revenues for Allegiance Coal Limited which ultimately affects reporting of revenues in the financial statements. The disparities in reporting of revenues figures if not identified during the audit process may lead to material misstatements of financial figures.
- Standard Regulations for Mining Companies
Different Australian states have enacted separate legislation in regard to exploration and extraction of minerals within their boundaries. However, similar regulatory approaches are adopted in each jurisdiction. The Mining Act and State Agreements deliberate on the entitlement to mine in different state and to exercise control over an interest on mineral deposit. Mining Acts is used by states to grant licenses to miners over a designated area while State Agreements are developed for specific large mining projects.
3.1 Mining Acts
Each state in Australia has its respective Mining Act which dictates the entitlements to mine state minerals on land owned by the state or even private lands. Laws inscribed in the Mining Acts prescribe the conditions for obtaining certain mineral interests. The governments within the states have also adopted a common licensing system to ensure administration of the mineral deposits. Mining licenses differs and the type issued by the state will largely depend on the project. Prospecting license allows the holder to prospects for minerals and has the advantage that there are certain priorities for grants or general purpose lease. Exploration license just like prospecting license allows the holder to explore minerals and a priority for grant. Retention license gives the holder to further explore mining as well priority for a grant. Mining lease is given to a miner as right to work and extract minerals from the land (PRACTICAL LAW 2).
The general purpose leases are given to allow miners to erect, place and operate machinery related to mining operations or any other specific purpose associated with mining. In addition to these mining licenses, there is a miscellaneous licenses granted to support building of infrastructures that support mining activities.
3.2 Registration of Mining Licenses and Lease.
The states maintain the registrar of mining licenses and leases issued over land. Any dealing in mining license must be legally registered by the state. Registration ensures that there is transparency in support of the overall mining license and lease system.
3.2 State Agreements
These are agreements negotiated between the applicable state government and the developers who intend to do mining. In a state agreement all the rights and obligations of both parties are outlined during the period of the development project. Before the state agreement is brokered the developer must demonstrate the ability to finance the project and provide a logical development plan. Commitment to the project by the miner can be demonstrated by the following criteria: preparation of a feasibility study which defines the project, addressing issues relating to environment and other indigenous issues and finally a proper identification of developer and the shareholders. Once all this procedures is done and settled, the state agreement is then ratified by the parliament. Ratification ensures that the state agreement stand above any provisions by other laws (PRACTICAL LAW 2).
3.3 Reporting Requirements
After a successful brokering of the state agreement, a miner will be bound by certain reporting obligations. The mining company will be required to publish an annual report of the mining activities in the area defined by the state agreement. There will be a requirement to submit a quarterly investigation reports on mining activities and some specific disclosures on the financial and market arrangements. These reporting requirements are important for monitoring the progress of the mining projects.
Areas of Concern in the Annual Financial Report 2017
4.1 Material Misstatements
Material misstatements are those errors that occur during the presentation of financial statements and could significantly affect the view of a business during a particular accounting period. Material misstatement is covered under the International Standards on Auditing (ISA) 450, Evaluation of Misstatements Identified during the Audit (Public Company Accounting Oversight Board 1). The areas of material misstatement in financial statements based on the assessment of the financial ratios and audit risk can either be internal or external to the business. Some of the common areas of material misstatement include inaccurate implications of accounting and tax laws, nature of the company, internal controls, capital structures and the performance measures of the company (IFAC 5).
4.2 Nature of the Company
Allegiance Coal Limited operates as a multinational coal mining company with presence in other countries. It presences of other countries and state affects its operations in terms of revenues and profits because of factors such as foreign exchange fluctuations and interruptions of its business operation due to events such as earthquakes. These are both internal and external risks that it faces that could lead to material misstatements. Failure to take into account the following factors when reporting its annual financial reports by auditor could lead to material misstatements and inaccurate reporting of financial results.
4.3 Capital Structure
The capital structure of a company is determined from the statement of financial position. Financial ratios such as debt to equity ratios can be manipulated and lead to a misstatement error during auditing. Manipulation is usually done to give a false view of the company’s financial position and source of financing. From the annual report of Allegiance Company the capital structure is majorly made up of equity than debts (borrowings plus long-term liabilities).
4.4 Company’s Financial Performance Measures
Some of the measures of a company financial performance include current ratio, quick ratio, return on equity, turnover ratios and gross margin. These financial ratios can be easily manipulated and give rise to the risk of misstatement to reflect perhaps high profitability or sales turnover which might not be the case. Audit process should check on the accuracy of these ratios to ensure they give a fair view of the company’s performance (IFAC 5).
- Financial Ratios
=Current assets/ current liabilities
Current ratio= 1,859,295/350,010
Current ratio= 1,429,101/2,063,015
= cash + cash equivalents+ trade and other receivables/current liabilities
= total liabilities/ total equity
= 933,232/ 4,144,066
= total debt/ total assets
= 2,063, 015/1,679, 101
Ordinary Earnings per Share
= (net income- preferred dividends)/ outstanding common shares
Return on Equity
=net income/ shareholder’s equity
Commentary On The Financial Performance
The above financial ratios show how the company has performance for the accounting period 2016 and 2017. Current ratio is used to show how the company is able to meet its short-term obligations. The current ratio for the year 2016 was 0.69 which has improved to 5.31 in the year 2017. This shows that the company liquid and it is able to meet its obligations when they fall due. In comparison with the industry average, the company is highly liquid especially in the year 2017 (ASX News 1).
Debt to equity ratio is used to assess the composition of the capital structure of the company. The company has more assets which it uses to generate more money hence it is less levered. Gearing ratio is also used to assess if the company can survive during economic downturn and it also shows the leverage of a firm.
In terms of profitability and assessment using the ordinary earning per share, the firm is not doing well and it not creating value for the shareholders. Ordinary earning per share is very low for both years (ASX News, ANNUAL REPORT 1).
The management of the firms is quite appalling as indicated by a negative return on equity. It is evident that the management decisions on investment are poor. The current management is not creating any value at all to the shareholders in the two successive years.
- Audit Assessment
Yes. I clearly understanding of the client business and audit risks will make it easier to conduct auditing and assurance taking keen consideration in areas of material misstatements to avoid problems with inaccurate financial reporting and audit related fiasco.
IFAC. International Standard on Auditing 315: Identifying and Assessing the Risks of Material Misstatement through Understanding the Entity And Its Environment. International Federation of Accountants, 2010. <www.ifac.org/system/files/downloads/a017-2010-iaasb-handbook-isa-315.pdf> Accessed 25 Aug. 2017.
Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. “AS 2110: Identifying and Assessing Risks of Material Misstatement.” PCAOB: Protecting Investors through Audit Oversight, Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, 2017. <pcaobus.org/Standards/Auditing/Pages/AS2110.aspx> Accessed 25 Aug. 2017.
Allegiance Coal Limited. Retrieved from http://www.allegiancecoal.com.au/irm/content/default.aspx
ASX News. (2017, September 08). Ann: 2017 Annual Report. Retrieved from https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/ann-2017-annual-report.3672729/#.WtkMQ4hubIU
ACCA. “Assessing the Risk of Material Misstatement | ACCA Global.” Global Body for Professional Accountants | Accountancy | ACCA | ACCA Global, ACCA Global, 2016. <www.accaglobal.com/my/en/member/discover/cpd-articles/audit-assurance/material-misstatement.html> Accessed 25 Aug. 2017.
Practical Law. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://uk.practicallaw.thomsonreuters.com/8-576-7530?transitionType=Default&contextData=(sc.Default)&firstPage=true&bhcp=1
PCAOB. “Auditing Standard No. 8.” PCAOB: Protecting Investors through Audit Oversight, Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, 2016. <pcaobus.org/Standards/Auditing/pages/auditing_standard_8.aspx> Accessed 25 Aug. 2017.